Skip to main content
Create interactive lessons using any digital content including wikis with our free sister product
. Get it on the
Pages and Files
Buncombe animal control
Feature Story Graphic Organizer
general websites (Aspca etc)
Group Feature Article Packet
No Kill Shelters
Writing a Feature Story
No Kill Shelters
Tweedle Dee and Tweedle Doo are two hound puppies with black and brown fur and thick wrinkles. They waddle and hop in their
cages and look through the bars at people who could adopt them. They are in the Asheville/Buncombe County Humane Society Shelter. They are two of the lucky ones, because the staff determined that they are adoptable and will not be euthanized. But there are other animals in the shelter that are not lucky like Tweedle Dee and Tweedle Doo because they are in a full access shelter and will be euthanized. There is also another type of shelter called a limited access shelter. That’s when a shelter does not put down animals for any reason. There is a big debate about full access shelters and limited access shelters.
The “Full access shelters are great,” says Jim Fulton, volunteer coordinator at the Asheville/Buncombe Humane Society, but he does agree that some full access shelters do have their problems. Like sometimes they put animals down just because they do not have enough room for them. Lucky for the animals in Buncombe county, our shelters don’t do that. Also, it’s legal for some shelters in North Carolina to still use gas chambers. Gas chambers are rooms where they put animals that fill up with gas and suffocates the animal to death. Nazis used this to kill the Jews in World War II. It’s a slow and painful death.Asheville/ Buncombe shelters do not use gas chambers. They give the animal a shot that puts the animal into a deep sleep then stops the heart so the animal does not feel it. They only do this if the animal is injured, sick, too aggressive or too old.
A limited access shelter is a shelter that does not euthanize an animal unless it is extremely sick or injured. An example in Asheville is the Animal Compassion Network. The ACN uses foster homes for animals. The foster owners take care of the animal until someone adopts it. The ACN sticks with the animal until it is adopted or dies. Val
Kula, a volunteer with ACN, says that ACN doesn't use the term limited access. They use the term "safe for life" which means that an animal that comes to them "will never, ever" go to a place where it will be euthanized.
They have a pet store, Pet Harmony, where they sell food and dog accessories like leashes and collars and brushes and beds. They do adoption events there. "Another thing that Animal Compassion Network does is offer obedience training," says Val Kula. This helps dogs be more adoptable. " Sometimes , unfortunately, an animal might be really wild but we'll do whatever we have to, use trainers or classes, to keep that dog alive." ACN is very careful about who adopts an animal. You have to fill out an application, then someone comes to your house to make sure it's a good match for the pet. They also check with your vet if you already have animals or had animals to make sure you'll give the animal good care.
Ms. Kula says we still do need full access shelters, too. Mr. Fulton says that if there weren't full access shelters we'd "have packs of wild dogs running around."
A solution to help stop the inhumane killing of animals in gas chambers in full access shelters is to pass a law that says gas chambers will be illegal in North Carolina and a law that says only an animal that is in serious pain , very old, very aggressive, or is too sick to be cured, can be put down. A way to get these laws to be passed is to talk to the Animal Compassion Network, a local shelter, or contact your legislators and see if they can help.
Remember Tweedle Dee and Tweedle Doo? They are the two hound puppies with black and brown fur and thick wrinkles at the shelter. They've probably already been adopted
there will always be unlucky animals that must be euthanized because they are old or sick or injured. Our conclusion is that we need full access shelters and limited access shelters. But we would like to see more limited access shelters than full access, because we want to see more animals have a chance and that would be in a limited access shelter. If you want to help solve this problem try donating or volunteering to your local shelter.
Tweedle Dee and Tweedle Doo are two hound puppies with black and brown fur and thick wrinkles. They waddle and hop in
cages and look through the bars at people who could adopt them. They are in the Asheville/Buncombe County Humane Society Shelter. They are two of the lucky ones, because the staff determined that they are adoptable and will not be euthanized. But there are other animals in the shelter that are not lucky like Tweedle Dee and Tweedle Doo
because they are in___ (what kind of shelter?). What is the other kind of shelter? What do people call them? Is there a big debate on which type is best?
(this is really in two parts--about full access and then about limited access)
“Full access shelters are great,” says Jim Fulton,(
Did he actually use the word great? and what are his reasons for saying this?
) but he does agree that full access shelters do have their problems. Like sometimes they put animals down just because they do not have enough room for them.
Does the Asheville Buncombe shelter do this--check your interview
it's legal for
in North Carolina
to still use gas chambers. Gas chambers are rooms they put animals, that fills up with gas and suffocates the animal to death.
used to use this to kill the
Jews WHEN? What kind of a death is it? Painful? Slow? How does the Asheville Buncombe shelter euthanize animals, Jim told you what they use and how they treat the animal while they are doing it. Again, WHY? There are more reasons than just because they don't have room. This information is on their website under FAQ or Frequently Asked Questions and in the interview you did with Jim Fulton. )
Describe a limited access shelter. Use the Animal Compassion Network as an example. Explain how they avoid euthanizing. Use a quote from the woman who came to talk with you. What the benefits to have limited access shelters? What are the challenges? What do they need to do if they can't place an animal right away?
Although full access shelters have their problems so do limited access shelters. Like where limited access shelters are there may be more strays running around free
How do you know this?
A solution to help stop the unnecessary
do you mean inhumane? How do you know the euthanizing is unncessary?
killing of animals in full access shelters is to pass a law that says gas chambers will be illegal in North Carolina and a law that says only animals in serious pain is to be put down
What if the animal is very old? What if the animal has bitten many people?
A way to get these laws to be passed is to talk to an animal compassion net work or a local shelter and see if they can help.
Think about this some more and look on the website to see if there is any information on how to contact your legislators--
Write a sentence here that links the conclusion to the two puppies in the first paragraph. You said that they are the lucky ones--and your conclusion is that there should be both types of shelters. Does this mean that there will always be unlucky animals that must be euthanized?
Our conclusion is that we need full access shelters and limited access shelters
WHY--SUMMARIZE WHAT YOU LEARNED.
But we would like to see more limited access shelters than full access
If you want to help solve this problem(
WHAT IS THE PROBLEM? THAT WE NEED FULL ACCESS SHELTERS BECAUSE WE HAVE SO MANY UNWANTED OR ABUSED PETS? OR IS IT TO IMPROVE THE LIVES OF ANIMALS THAT ARE IN SHELTERS?
try donating or volunteering to your local shelter.
CAN YOU GIVE MORE SPECIFIC INFORMATION?
No Kill Shelters--Essay on the pros and cons
Animal Compassion Network
Asheville Humane Society
Brother Wolf Animal Rescue
help on how to format text
Turn off "Getting Started"